Get There Quick!

Want to skip background info and go straight to the collars?

Training collars can be a great way to help enforce positive habits for any dog. Contrary to a misconception some people have, they don’t hurt the dog. Collars use different methods to get the dog’s attention, from sound, to a vibration, to a very minor shock. The shock isn’t enough to hurt the dog, it’s just enough for a mild discomfort. Before we take a look at some of the best collars out there, let’s take a look at some of the behaviors that they can correct.

Unwanted barking: This can be a nuisance not just for you, but for your neighbors as well. Even if they aren’t complaining to you, they could still very well be getting extremely annoyed at the sound of your dog’s constant barking, especially if it takes place at unusual hours. Maybe you’re not even home when this happens? Some people don’t care at all what their neighbors think, but most good neighbors will feel a certain sense of anxiety, and a desire to correct the behavior.

A training collar, however, isn’t the ideal choice for this. You’ll be better off with a no-bark collar in particular. There are, however, some training collars for dogs that also include an anti-bark device, more on that soon!

Have a Smaller dog? Don't worry, we reviewed those too. Click here to read our small dog training collar reviews.

Not acknowledging you when you call them: When you call your dog’s name, you want them to drop whatever they’re doing and come to you immediately, right? Well, if that’s not the case, don’t worry. This is another behavior that can be taught by using a training collar for your dog.

Digging around the yard: Is your dog digging holes and you wish they would stop? Dog’s love to dig, but if they’re digging up your garden or leaving unwanted holes in the yard, that’s something that will need to be corrected with training.

Jumping all over your furniture or guests: If you don’t want your dog on your furniture, that’s your choice, but it can be a difficult behavior to teach.

Also, not every guest is going to appreciate having your dog jumping up on them. They might say it’s okay when you tell your dog to get down, but all that’s doing is making the training even harder since they’re being rewarded for bad behavior by your guests petting them and giving them positive reinforcement to something you’re trying to stop them from doing.

These are just a few of the behaviors that you may be looking to kick to the curb as a dog owner, there are others that can be trained-away using some of the collars we’re going to be featuring today.    

The difference between training collars and no-bark collars

The main difference here is that the no-bark collars are activated by the dog’s bark, whereas the training collars are activated by you, holding a wireless remote control. You could, in theory, still use a training collar to train the dog not to bark, but as we mentioned earlier – it’s not recommended. You aren’t going to be near your dog 24/7, so when they realize that they can bark whenever you aren’t around, as long as they’re quiet when you’re home, that isn’t really addressing the problem, and it’s teaching the wrong lesson.

Both options can come with a lot of the same features, like a mild shock, or a vibration, or a sound, but one is used passively and the other will require your active attention in the training process. Some of these collars are going to include anti-bark, so that’s a great bonus!

Choosing the correct probe length for your dog

There are generally two options in terms of the length of the contacts on the collar. Not every collar is going to include both sizes, but some will. Make sure you’re getting one with the correct length of probes for your particular breed of dog. Generally speaking, shorter contact probes are for dogs with short coats and longer probes are for dogs with longer coats.

Vibration is better than tone

Different trainers have their preferences, but if you have more than one dog, vibration will almost certainly be the better option. Tone is too easy to get confused with other sounds like cell phones or the oven. You don’t want your dog learning to react anytime they hear a beep sound that reminds them of their collar, that’s much too confusing and adds unnecessary stress.

Speaking of which, when you have more than one dog, using the tone feature can be counter-productive. If you use the tone for one dog, and then correct their behavior, but the other dog hears the tone – they’ll wonder what they did wrong.

Dog Training Collars for a Positive Training Experience

Positive re-enforcement is the best way to train dogs, according to many people, and works very well with the assistance of a collar, just as long as the dog isn’t getting mixed messages, or messages that were meant for a different pup.

Alright, with some of the basics out of the way, let’s start taking a look at some of the options out there in the market. The rest of this article will serve as a buyer’s guide as we take a look at a few different models. Every item on this page has a few things in common:

  • Great reviews.
  • Great value for the price.
  • Tried, tested, and true.
  • Created with your dog’s well-being in mind.

And we’ve chosen options to fit a variety of budgets. One thing that’s always important as we put together our buyer’s guides is to ensure that if one unit costs more than another unit, that it’s actually worth the money. If we recommend something cheaper, it’s still going to be plenty good enough. If we recommend something more expensive, it’s absolutely going to be better than the cheaper models, but we wouldn’t recommend anything that isn’t decent in the first place – even if it’s very cheap.

Alright, are you ready to take a look at some of the best dog training collars, and shock collars for your dogs?


Aetertek Professional 919C

electronic dog training collar


This is right around the lower price range that you’ll want to consider. Sure, there are plenty of options in the $20-$30 range, but a lot of them seem to be the same device – just rebranded by different companies. That isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it’s worth it to spend a bit more so that you aren’t knee-deep in the entry-level, especially for something this important.

So, at around $70 for their one-dog system (And just over $100 for a two-dog unit), we’re considering this the budget option on this list – even thought they were much cheaper devices out there.

Click Here for the Lowest Price

Some of the noteworthy features of this device, besides the price, are the fact that it’s completely 100% waterproof. If your dog loves to play in the rain, or jump into the water when you’re at the lake, or whatever – you don’t have to worry about the device becoming ruined.

This unit has 4 function modes: Shock, vibration, beep, and an automatic anti-bark. The auto anti-bark is nice. Earlier on, we discussed how manual collars won’t work great for bark training since you’d need to be there constantly. Well, this solves that problem, by essentially combining both products into one.

This device includes an LCD display, something that you don’t always see in less-expensive models and even some expensive models don’t have. Everything comes packaged in a carrying case and is easy to figure out.

  • Product
  • Features
  • Photos
    • 100% waterproof and rechargeable.
    • LCD displays various information about the collar. Correction level, and training mode.
    • Mainly used for stubborn dogs that need correction.


Let’s take a step up into a higher-quality device at a higher price. It’s still very reasonable when you consider the countless benefits, and affordable enough that most dog owners can spring for it over a cheaper model without breaking the bank, in the grand scheme of things.

This device includes both sets of contact probes, making it suitable for different coat lengths, whether your pup likes to try out different hairstyles, or to hold onto re-sale value when you no longer need it. In any case, these are good to have.

Note: This is just for the collar; you’ll still need the remote control end of it. There are different ones to choose from, but if you’d like to get everything in one package, take a look at the next item that we’re going to be featuring, which is the complete Garmin Pro 70 dog training system.

Click Here for the Lowest Price

Garmin PT10 Dog Device

71VHgUFGHxL._SL1500_


But first, let’s talk a bit more about the PT10 collar. It also includes a built-in bark training system to teach your dog not to bark unnecessarily.

One of the nice things about buying the collars and the handheld parts separately is that you can upgrade one piece, or another, down the road. Perhaps you don’t want the most expensive remote control, but you want to spend more on the collar instead. You’ll need to make sure they’re compatible, of course. For example, this collar works with both the Pro 70 and the Pro 550 handhelds.

You can use one single remote control to train 3-6 dogs, depending on which handheld you choose, so that’s the main reason that somebody would want to buy the handhelds and collars separately. For example, you could buy six of these collars to use with one single Pro 70 unit, or 3 of these collars to use with the Pro 550 model, all by Garmin.

  • Product
  • Features
  • Photos
      • Range of up to 1 mile.
      • Package comes with collar, charger, probes, and manual.

Garmin PRO 70 Handheld
71iLc8hmb8L._SL1500_



This unit costs about $100 less than the PRO 550 model, but allows you to train twice as many dogs and to individually select their levels of stimulation. This is just for the handheld, and doesn’t include the collar, for reasons that we outline above. But, if you’d like this unit, and a collar, check out the next option.

If you already have the collar, and you’re trying to decide between this unit or the 550 model, the two main things to consider are how many dogs you’re training, and how much you’d like to spend. Beyond the number of dogs, there are other differences.

Click Here for the Lowest Price

The Pro 550 offers 21 levels of continuous or momentary stimulation, whereas this one (The Pro 70) only offers 6 levels of continuous stimulation. You’ll want to go with the option that suits your training style. If you need the extra levels of stimulation, and are training 3 dogs or less, the 550 is the way to go. If six levels of continuous stimulation for your dog are suitable to your needs, and/or you need to train 3-6 dogs, go with the Pro 70.

  • Product
  • Features
  • Photos
    • 1 mile range.
    • Includes just the remote, the collar can actually be ordered above. Also comes with charger and manual.


Here’s a combination of a collar and the Pro 70 handheld. These devices basically set the standard, they’re very popular and for good reason. We’ve already discussed both of them on their own, so there isn’t a lot to add, other than the fact that Garmin is known for making quality devices across a variety of categories, and unless you need the features offered by the Pro 550 or other very high-end devices, this guy right here will serve you very well.

Click Here for the Lowest Price

Garmin Pro 70 Dog Training System
61FaVZwuhZL._SL1000_


  • Product
  • Features
  • Photos
    • 6 Levels of stimulation
    • Comes with handheld controller, collar, strap, charger, probes, wrench, and manual.
    • Built to last.
    • Electronic stimulation of both shock and tone.

Lastly, we’ll take a look at a very high-end unit, also from Garmin. It’s the most expensive item on our list, and for good reason.


Garmin Pro Trashbreaker Dog Training System

51MJJyBZeDL._SL1000_



If finding a training collar for your dog is serious business, here’s the collar that means business. It’s really easy to use, and can support up to 9 dogs with a frequency range of 4 miles. It includes advanced bark correction technology, the handheld device, and the collar. This package has everything you need, which you’d obviously expect at this price.

It’s not a huge jump in cost from the previous model, all things considered, and relatively speaking, so it might be worth the upgrade, depending on which you prefer. Does range matter to you? This device has an incredible four-mile range.

 

Click Here for the Lowest Price
  • Product
  • Features
  • Photos
      • Up to a 4 mile range, perfect for the outdoorsmen.
      • Garmin's Barklimiter technology.
      • Comes with the handheld, collar, antenna, collar strap, charger, probes, and manual.
      • Built to last
      • Train with sound and electronic stimulation.

You can’t go wrong with any of the devices we’ve looked at, just make sure that the features they have fit your needs. They’re all quality, and every single one of them can help you achieve the results as you and your dog embark together down the road towards a happy, well-trained lifestyle.

Leave a Comment: